Smoked Old Fashioned Recipe

Sharing is caring!

Make an old fashioned cocktail with a modern twist! This smoked old fashioned brings a fun twist to the classic bourbon cocktail, make it your signature cocktail at your Halloween party!

Love fabulous cocktails that are Halloween worthy? Try this love potion, a poisoned apple cocktail, or some mulled pumpkin cider!

Elevate your cocktail game with a smoked old fashioned cocktail

I've always felt that a classic old fashioned was for the 'serious bourbon drinker', but this fun twist makes it more of an awesome --and spooky-- drink that's perfect for a Halloween dinner party or any dinner party!

Foghat smokers are really easy to find and affordable, and you can use any kind of wood chips to take a simple cocktail and elevate the flavors into something unexpected.

This smoked old fashioned cocktail is an easy and fun recipe that should be a part of any home bartender's repertoire!

This post may contain Affiliate Links. Please see my Full Disclosure Policy for more details.

Jump to:

• Elevate your cocktail game with a smoked old fashioned cocktail
• History of the Old Fashioned Cocktail
• Equipment
• The Best Cocktail Smokers: Foghat cocktail smoker or Smoking Gun
• Key Ingredients
• The Best Bourbon for Old Fashioneds
• Best Bitters for Old Fashioned Cocktail recipes
• Smoke a Cocktail: What kind of Wood to Use
• How to Make a Smoked Old Fashioned 
• Variations and Substitutions
• Pro Tips
• FAQs
• More Whiskey / Bourbon cocktail recipes:
• 📖 Recipe

History of the Old Fashioned Cocktail

Old Fashioneds actually go back to the early 1800's, being a mix of sugar, water, bitters, and spirits, garnished with a cocktail cherry or orange peel.

It was simple and potent, but as more complex cocktails came into play by 1850s and '60s, the cocktail came back en vogue in New York City for those who were used to the simple cocktails of the early 1800's...with the name 'the old fashioned'.

It's now one of the most popular and top selling drinks internationally.

Equipment

Double old fashioned glass - this is also called a 'rocks glass', and it's the classic choice for this cocktail.

Cocktail smoker or smoke gun - I use an old fashioned cocktail smoker top, let it sit on the top of the glass for a couple of minutes to let that smoke really infuse before removing.

Wood Chips - You can buy wood chips for smoking cocktails easily on Amazon, at some boutique distillery, 

Culinary Torch - a must to burn the wood. A regular lighter just doesn't seem to add smoke in the same amount.

The Best Cocktail Smokers: Foghat cocktail smoker or Smoking Gun

There are two types of cocktail smokers: an individual cocktail smoker and the smoking gun.

In this recipe I used a foghat-style smoker, which is perfect when you're making only one or two cocktails at home. It sits on top of the drink, with a chimney where wood chips are burned and the smoke floats down onto the cocktail. 

These chimney-shaped smokers are more affordable than the gun smokers and are easier to use, in my opinion, to add smoke to your drink.

This smoker gives the individual guest the ability to smoke their own cocktail and helps create a magical cocktail experience at your next party. 

The other type is the smoking gun, which is a small handheld device more versatile in its usage and you can do things like make a cloche full of smoked cocktails or smoke other foods with it. It's also much more expensive and can have a learning curve. 

Key Ingredients

Twist of Orange Peel - orange zest is a classic ingredient in an old fashioned, I also like adding a maraschino cherry since we love sweet flavors in our drinks.

Dashes of Angostura Bitters - Angostura bitters are spicy and bitter, with notes of cloves and cinnamon.

Good Bourbon - Use your favorite barrel-proof bourbon, a bourbon that's nice and strong and smooth. That doesn't have to mean expensive, but it does mean enjoyable!

Sugar Cube - I like the richness from raw sugar that you won't get with the traditional white sugar cube, but if you're not into sugar you can use pure maple syrup.

A Large Ice Cube - one large ice cube is how you serve a classic old fashioned cocktail. I used this skull ice mold, it really made an awesome ice cube!

The Best Bourbon for Old Fashioneds

Here's what I've gathered about the best liquor for this classic cocktail:

• Look for a whiskey or bourbon that is at least 90 proof, so it doesn't dilute as the ice melts.
• Because this is a whiskey cocktail with such simple ingredients, choose your whiskey wisely. Bourbons are more sweet, while rye whiskey is more *spicy*.
• Want a few of my favorites? These are a few classic brands that do not disappoint: Uncle Nearest, Maker's Mark, and Woodford Reserve.

Best Bitters for Old Fashioned Cocktail recipes

Bitters are highly concentrated alcohol-based tinctures used sparingly to flavor cocktails, used as medicines, or even in food! There are two classic bitters types to consider:

• Angostura Bitters - a classic bitter in the old fashioned cocktail, made by the House of Angostura in Trinidad and Tobago. It's made with gentian, clove, cinnamon, and other spices and herbs, so these bitters have a spicy
• Orange Bitters - these are bitters made with Seville orange peels, burnt sugar, and spices like coriander, cardamom, and anise. Orange bitters are sweeter

Smoke a Cocktail: What kind of Wood to Use

In our experience, my husband and I have different tastes when it comes to the smoke in an old fashioned cocktail. I personally love the more delicate, sweeter flavors of maple or cherry wood, he actually likes the smoky, spicy flavor hickory with his old fashioneds. This is also a good thing to know whether you are using a sweeter bourbon or spicier rye whiskey.

This post all about the different woods and variations one can use to change and add smoke flavor to a cocktail, so give it a read if you want to dive into all the different ways you can use smoke to flavor a cocktail.

How to Make a Smoked Old Fashioned 

Steps 1 and 2 are optional, but I enjoy double smoking the old fashioned! They add extra smoke flavor to your cocktail and a depth of flavor to each ingredient. 

Variations and Substitutions

There are tons of great options to give more twists and unique spins on an old fashioned, simple ones like a change in garnish to more advanced things like smoking ice or smoking your sweetener.

Sprig of Rosemary - not only will this add those aromatic terpenes, you can use it like a seasonal swizzle stick.

Orange Slice - a whole orange slice is pretty traditional in old fashioned cocktails

Luxardo Cherries - Instead of sweet maraschinos, these sour cherries are soaked in luxardo liqueur. They're more expensive but more luxe, too.

Cinnamon Stick - another seasonal swizzle stick, it'll also release those wonderful oils it has and lend its flavor to your old fashioned.

Pure Maple Syrup - smoked maple syrup can be used in lieu of the sugar cube, you can smoke it in the glass using the method I talked about above in the Instruction section.

Pro Tips

If using the smoking gun to add smoke to the cocktail, use a piece of saran wrap over the rim of the glass to hold it in or use a cloche!

Love sweeter cocktails? Go for another sugar cube and smoke sweeter woods and flavors like vanilla beans, cinnamon sticks, and maple wood.

FAQs

More Whiskey / Bourbon cocktail recipes:

📖 Recipe