Pan-Seared NY Strips with Mushroom Cream Sauce

Sharing is caring!

New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. My hubby's favorite way to have steak, you've got to try it!

New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. The hubby's favorite way to have steak!

My mother-in-law took Grey for a sleep over (let me tell you how excited that boy gets about spending time with his grandparents and uncles!) Father's Day weekend, so I made something special that Brian really wanted. He's a meat and potatoes man, so what's more perfect than a medium rare New York strip and garlic parm smashed potatoes?

Steaks are 'any occasion that pops up' food.

Birthday? Steak.

Valentine's Day? Steak.

Mother's and Father's Days? Steak.

Christmas? Prime Rib....aka dino-steak.

New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. The hubby's favorite way to have steak!PIN THIS NEW YORK STRIP RECIPE NOW IN YOUR DATE NIGHT, STEAKHOUSE, AND SPECIAL OCCASION BOARDS ON PINTEREST. AND FOLLOW SWEET TEA & THYME ON PINTEREST FOR MORE TIPS, HACKS, AND TASTY RECIPES!

We love a good steak. And by steak, I mean rib-eye, NY strip, filet mignon, a nice tomahawk porterhouse that's like 40 oz. The ones served at the good steakhouse with the wood walls and there's usually truffled-something and lobster mac and cheese lurking somewhere in the menus.

Sure, skirt steak and flank steak are all 'steak' but they're not the kind you think of when you think 'steak'. They're quick cooking, more affordable, often tough and need to be tenderized, and more suited for things like being put in tacos, grilled hot and quick for carne asada.

NY strip steaks are usually more Brian's choice for date night in; they're a flavorful cut, beefier than a filet mignon and they have that fat cap over side, which is rendered down in the pan, rather than the looser integrated fat that's often in a ribeye.

I like to pan sear them over high heat, but I like mine blue, while my husband just got into medium rare. He didn't know the amazing, flavorful goodness that was a medium rare steak until I mentioned it's how Gordon Ramsay eats steak.

Brian is sold on anything 'Gordon Ramsay'.New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. The hubby's favorite way to have steak!

Using a meat thermometer is the best way to make sure your steak is up to your desired temperature, I highly suggest investing in one for the perfect steak.

If you eat steak over medium, and especially a leaner cut like a New York strip or a Chateaubriand or filet mignon, just go buy an inexpensive piece of meat. Overcooking will lead to dry, flavorless, chewy (and not in a good way) steak...aka steak that needs a sauce (or ketchup) rather than just be accompanied by an optional sauce.

And...well, what's the point of buying a nice, expensive piece of meat if you don't get to enjoy it in all it's tender, juicy, buttery glory?New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. The hubby's favorite way to have steak!

Like I said, this is Brian's meal, so after this butter-basted New York strip is set to the side to rest, the awesome, flavorful fond is deglazed from the pan and creates a wonderful mushroom cream sauce. It's absolutely delicious and Brian just cannot stop talking about this sauce, it's rich and creamy and really, they make the perfect pair.

I also served with lemony sauteed asparagus, and crispy smashed garlic parmesan potatoes. Yum. But you can enjoy this with anything you like, dinner rolls, mac and cheese, a salad...

Definitely the perfect date night dinner...or in this case, Father's Day dinner.

Looking for a side dish to serve with this? Check out:
Hasselback Potatoes
Baked Macaroni and Cheese
One Bowl Cheddar Bay Biscuits
Smooth and Creamy Mashed Potatoes


Don't forget to PIN this New York Strip steak to Pinterest!

New York strip steak: tender, beefy, basted with garlic butter and served with a mushroom cream pan sauce. The hubby's favorite way to have steak!

shop this recipe

[amazon_link asins='B00L4771OG,B00004OCK1,B01F9NXFC2' template='ProductCarousel' store='sweetteaandth-20' marketplace='US' link_id='7374f8dd-7527-11e8-a8f1-4b47e9af7957']



📖 Recipe

Pan Seared New York Strip Steaks with Mushroom Cream Sauce

4.92 from 23 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Additional Time 1 hour
Total Time 1 hour 20 minutes
Course Dinner
Cuisine American
Servings 2 New York Strips


  • 2 1-½ inch thick New York Strip Steaks
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
  • 2 tablespoons grapeseed or vegetable oil
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 6 cloves garlic peeled and smashed

Mushroom Cream Sauce

  • ¼ cup beef stock
  • 1 cup sliced cremini or button mushrooms
  • ½ cup heavy cream
  • Juice of ½ lemon
  • Salt and pepper to taste


  • Let steaks rest at room temperature for 1 hour on a wire rack (preferably) or on a plate, seasoned on all sides with salt and pepper, before searing. Pat steaks dry on all sides with paper towel to ensure a flavorful crust forms while cooking.
  • Heat a large cast-iron skillet or large steel pan over medium-high heat with 2 tablespoon grapeseed oil or vegetable oil. When the pan begins smoking, lay the steaks into the pan away from you, and leave the steak alone for 2-3 minutes, or until a golden brown crust forms. Flip the steak with tongs, then reduce the heat to medium.
  • Add 4 tablespoons of butter and smashed garlic cloves to the pan. Baste the steaks: using heat resistant oven gloves or a pan handle cover so you don't burn your hands, very carefully tilt the pan toward you so the butter and garlic pools in the pan, pour the butter over the steaks generously with a large spoon.
  • Baste constantly while cooking for 1 to 2 minutes (rare-ish, medium rare), or until the steaks are done to your liking. With your tongs, hold the steak on it's side and hold the fatty side to the pan for 30 seconds to render the fat until it's golden brown. Set steaks on a plate to rest, pouring most of the pan juices over the steaks and sitting about 3 garlic cloves on top of the steaks while resting.
  • While the steaks are resting, sauté the mushrooms and remaining garlic in the remaining pan juices on medium heat, then cook until browned and soft. Add the beef stock and cream, add lemon juice and let simmer down for about 5 minutes, stirring occasionally, then season with salt and pepper to your taste.
  • Serve steak with the mushroom cream sauce immediately.
Tried this recipe?Leave a star rating and let us know!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Pingback: New York Strip with Mushroom Cream Sauce - Yum Goggle
  2. Pingback: Fresh Spicy Tuna Avocado Towers | Sweet Tea and Thyme
  3. Pingback: Easy Mushroom Risotto Recipe | Sweet Tea & Thyme
  4. This is making my mouth water!!!

  5. Sondria Harp says:

    This sounds delicious! And thank god you talked that man into eating his streak medium rare, you're a good wife!

  6. What a great meal to have while the little one is with the grandparents! That looks so delicious!

  7. That steak is perfectly cooked and that sauce? Holy cow (no pun intended!) does it sound good!!! Waiting until the steaks are grilled and resting to make the sauce is smart. It forces you to let them rest. The sauce looks amazing!

  8. Lisa Huff says:

    LOVE mushrooms and beef together. This is my kind of dinner!! Pinning!

    1. I'm glad you like it! Thanks for pinning!

  9. Jeff Honeywood says:

    That mushroom cream sauce is the perfect accompaniment to a perfectly cooked steak. I'm going to have to give this a try.

    1. Please do! I love recipe feedback

  10. Edyta at Innocent Delight says:

    In my world mushrooms are always going great with good piece of meat. Your steak and mushroom sauce look fantastic.

    1. Same here, mushroom and meat are made for each other. And thanks!

  11. Katie | Healthy Seasonal Recipes says:

    We do steaks for date night too. I love the chance to have one at home with my hubbie as well. These look great.

    1. Is it ever date night without steak? ?

  12. I can think of a few people who would love this!
    Happy Fathers' Day!

  13. Oh wow! You had me at garlic butter! This steak looks incredible paired with the mushroom cream sauce. Definitely perfect for Father's Day.

    1. Garlic butter + mushroom cream sauce + steak= basically irresistible! Lol thank you for stopping by!

  14. This looks like a fantastic Father's Day meal! Perfect for Dad!

    1. All it's missing is the dad sandals and a grill, right? ?