A Midwestern favorite. Juicy Lucy’s patty has a secret: molten cheese inside! 

Juicy Lucy Burger - Sweet Tea & Thyme

 

Have you ever been to a restaurant that served Juicy Lucies? I haven’t, unfortunately; but that’s because I’ve never been to the midwest. They are all the rage there, according to the Travel Channel, haha.

A Juicy Lucy, if you don’t know, is a burger with the cheese on the inside of the patty. Boom. That’s it; but it’s somehow just so amazingly delicious even though it’s so simple. A big pinch of cheese is placed in the middle of half the burger patty, then the top of the patty is placed on top and pinched around all sides so there aren’t any holes for the cheese to ooze out, and cook!. I don’t think it gets any better than that, honestly.

Juicy Lucy Burger - Sweet Tea & Thyme

So while I can’t attest to the deliciousness of an authentic Juicy Lucy, I can attest to the deliciousness of homemade ones. I love a good cheeseburger. Five Guys, Shake Shack, any burger joint that’s known for being a burger joint and has a good burger, I am so here for it.

Juicy Lucy Burger - Sweet Tea & Thyme

But for some reason, homemade just always tastes better. Nothing beats a medium-cooked burger that’s super juicy and flavorful because you took love, care, and time into making it, you know?

Juicy Lucy Burger - Sweet Tea & Thyme

I like my burger patty well seasoned, but I know some just like a little salt and pepper. I love using grated colby jack cheese because it melts very easily, mixed with sharp cheddar for flavor. You can use any type of cheese you want, but I will always suggest using a 80%-85% lean/fat ratio ground chuck/sirloin for the patties for the best flavor and texture. And potato buns. Because, well, there’s just something magical about potato buns…

Juicy Lucy Burger
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Author:
Serves: 6 burgers
Ingredients
  • 2 lbs 50/50 mix of ground sirloin and (80/20) chuck, resting for 30 mins
  • ¼ cup colby jack cheese, shredded
  • Kosher Salt and Pepper, to taste
  • Toppings and Potato Hamburger Buns
Instructions
  1. Season the ground beef with salt and pepper well, use about 1 tsp salt and pepper each and mix well with your hands. Take about ⅓ lb of raw ground beef and split into two. Flatten the beef into thin patties, then take a big pinch of cheese and put it into the middle of one. Cover the cheese with the other patty and seal the edges of the two patties together with a fork's prongs. Repeat for the rest of the meat and cheese.
  2. Heat a grill pan on high heat and sear for a minute each on both sides. Turn temperature to medium and allow to cook to preferred temperature.For medium, about 5 minutes; medium-well, 6-7 minutes.
  3. Let the burger rest for 3 minutes, cheese will be burning hot otherwise. Then serve with your favorite toppings on buns.